What's Hot

    Eloy P&Z Hears Dual Requests for Major Land Use Overhaul

    August 1, 2025

    State’s Largest Data Center Project Part of Vermaland Pinal Plan

    August 1, 2025

    Pinal Considering 215-Acre Data Center Development

    August 1, 2025
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    AZBEX
    NEWS TICKER
    • [August 1, 2025] - Eloy P&Z Hears Dual Requests for Major Land Use Overhaul
    • [August 1, 2025] - State’s Largest Data Center Project Part of Vermaland Pinal Plan
    • [August 1, 2025] - Pinal Considering 215-Acre Data Center Development
    • [August 1, 2025] - Hundred-Unit Skyline Towns Townhome Development Moves Forward in Apache Junction
    • [August 1, 2025] - Arizona Projects 08-01-25
    • [July 29, 2025] - Scottsdale Hospitals War May Heat Up with New Banner Request
    • [July 29, 2025] - Dominium Planning 304-Unit BTR in Surprise
    • [July 29, 2025] - Next Steps Coming for Bartlett Dam Expansion
    Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
    • Home
    • News
      1. View Latest
      2. Planning & Development
      3. Local News
      4. Classifieds
      5. Editorial Analysis
      6. Budgets & Funding
      7. Commercial Real Estate
      8. People on the Move
      9. Arizona Projects
      10. Legislation & Regulations
      11. Trends

      Eloy P&Z Hears Dual Requests for Major Land Use Overhaul

      August 1, 2025

      State’s Largest Data Center Project Part of Vermaland Pinal Plan

      August 1, 2025

      Pinal Considering 215-Acre Data Center Development

      August 1, 2025

      Hundred-Unit Skyline Towns Townhome Development Moves Forward in Apache Junction

      August 1, 2025

      Mohave County May Remove Data Centers as Economic Development Goal

      July 23, 2025

      Ariz. Construction Gained 600 Jobs in June

      July 22, 2025

      Scottsdale Report Shows Multifamily Pipeline Half of Common Estimate

      July 22, 2025

      Alleging Breaches, ZenniHome Closes NGS Operations

      July 21, 2025

      Scottsdale Hospitals War May Heat Up with New Banner Request

      July 29, 2025

      Glendale Voters to Determine VAI Resort’s Fate

      May 16, 2025

      Legislation Would Effectively Strip NIMBYs of Referendum Tool

      February 11, 2025

      2025 Forecast Tries to Clarify an Uncertain Market

      February 7, 2025

      Ariz. LIHTC to Sunset Under New Budget

      July 8, 2025

      State Government Shutdown Averted as Hobbs Signs Budget

      July 1, 2025

      Arterial Life Cycle Program Covers 20 Years of Street Development

      June 27, 2025

      $56M+ MAG Program will Enable $90M in Arterial Street Widening Projects

      June 24, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 07-29-25

      July 29, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 07-22-25

      July 22, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 07-15-25

      July 15, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 07-08-25

      July 8, 2025

      Industry Professionals 07-29-25

      July 29, 2025

      Industry Professionals 07-22-25

      July 22, 2025

      Industry Professionals 07-15-25

      July 15, 2025

      Industry Professionals 07-08-25

      July 8, 2025

      Arizona Projects 08-01-25

      August 1, 2025

      Arizona Projects 07-25-25

      July 25, 2025

      Arizona Projects 07-18-25

      July 18, 2025

      Arizona Projects 07-11-25

      July 11, 2025

      Mohave County May Remove Data Centers as Economic Development Goal

      July 23, 2025

      Alleging Breaches, ZenniHome Closes NGS Operations

      July 21, 2025

      Ariz. LIHTC to Sunset Under New Budget

      July 8, 2025

      Tax Bill Would Make LIHTC Permanent

      July 2, 2025

      Ariz. Construction Gained 600 Jobs in June

      July 22, 2025

      BEX Updates Construction Sector Projections in Annual Mid-Year Update

      July 18, 2025

      Phoenix Industrial Sees First Vacancy Drop in Years; YoY Completions Drop 75%

      July 18, 2025

      Phoenix Construction Costs See 4.42% Q2 Annual Change

      July 15, 2025

      Eloy P&Z Hears Dual Requests for Major Land Use Overhaul

      August 1, 2025

      State’s Largest Data Center Project Part of Vermaland Pinal Plan

      August 1, 2025

      Pinal Considering 215-Acre Data Center Development

      August 1, 2025

      Hundred-Unit Skyline Towns Townhome Development Moves Forward in Apache Junction

      August 1, 2025
    • AZBEX
      • Subscribe
      • Classifieds
      • Advertising
    • DATABEX
      • Webinars
      • Monthly Snapshot
    • Events
      • 2025 Mid-Year Update
      • 2025 Industrial LMS
    • About Us
      • Meet the Company
      • Meet the Sales Team
      • Meet the Editorial Team
      • Meet the BEXperts
    • CIP Special Report
    AZBEX
    Home » Legislation & Regulations » The State of Arizona Affordability Legislation and Policy Snapshot
    Legislation & Regulations

    The State of Arizona Affordability Legislation and Policy Snapshot

    BEX StaffBy BEX StaffJuly 7, 2023No Comments7 Mins Read
    Phoenix City Hall. Credit: City of Phoenix
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    By Roland Murphy for AZBEX

    The National Association of Homebuilders recently released an overview of Inclusionary Zoning laws around the United States.

    Prepared by Hinckley, Allen & Snyder LLP, the 106-page “Policy, Practical, and Legal Challenges to Inclusionary Zoning: A Resource Manual for NAHB Members” offers a state-by-state look at inclusionary zoning and “provides a list of policy, practical and legal strategies that NAHB members may adopt when dealing with inclusionary zoning proposals, as well as an accessible guide to state statutory and case law authority for municipal or county governments to enact inclusionary zoning ordinances,” according to the announcement.

    While inclusionary zoning is often combined with other legislative and policy issues in discussions on housing affordability, the report follows a multifaceted but narrow legal definition. The announcement says, “‘Inclusionary zoning’ is defined as any municipal or county ordinance that requires or allows a property owner, builder or developer to restrict the sale or resale price or rent of a specified percentage of residential units in development as a condition of receiving permission to construct that development. This definition covers both voluntary inclusionary programs—in which the owner/builder/developer has an option to impose price restrictions, usually in return for certain incentives—and mandatory programs — in which the price or rent restrictions are a condition of approval. This definition also includes ordinances that allow payment of a fee as a way to opt out of an inclusionary program.”

    Inclusionary Zoning in Arizona

    Despite the appeal of inclusionary zoning among liberal housing policy advocates and the state’s increasingly leftward political shift in recent years, Arizona remains one of four states that have some statutory prohibitions against inclusionary zoning.

    The two primary pieces of legislation against inclusionary zoning in Arizona are The Private Property Rights Protection Act—Arizona Revised Statutes 12-1131, also known as Proposition 207—and ARS 11-819.

    Voters approved Prop 207 in 2006. The measure restricts eminent domain and entitles landowners to compensation if a land use law is enacted that reduces a property’s fair market value. Nearly every zoning package regarding property use includes a statement of compliance asserting it does not violate the prohibition.

    ARS 11-819 is more specific. It prevents counties from adopting general plan provisions, land use regulations and conditions for building or use permits that establish a set price for residential housing units or lots or that require units or lots “to be designated for sale or lease to any particular class or group of residents.” However, it does allow for the creation of incentives, density bonuses and other voluntary conditions intended to increase low- and moderate-income housing.

    Cities and counties have made use of the second section of ARS 11-819 for a range of projects. Generally speaking, the governmental body and the developer agree that the development will dedicate a specific number or percentage of units for availability at lower-than-market rates in exchange for variances like height or density maximums. Since development agreements are technically voluntary and result from mutual negotiations for individual projects, the parties are free to set wider terms than would be possible under set mandates. Similar provisions have been used for public benefit considerations like art installations and communal gathering areas.

    East Valley Representative Melody Hernandez, D-District 8, introduced a bill this January that would have repealed ARS 11-819, among other measures increasing municipal control over zoning and development issues. That bill was held in committees after a second read in the House.

    Other Inclusionary Legislative Efforts

    Inclusionary zoning was one of many affordability-related topics targeted by former legislator Steve Kaiser in various bills in the last few years. Some of the measures, including the proposed but eventually tabled House Bill 2674 co-sponsored by Democratic Representative César Chávez, that would have established “zoning by right” for housing development on some commercially zoned properties, were apparently intended to spark zoning reform discussions and serve as a “shot across the bow” for municipalities like Scottsdale, Fountain Hills and Sedona, among others, that have embraced an anti-development stance in recent years. (AZBEX Feb. 8, 2022; Feb. 15, 2022; Feb. 22, 2022)

    The takeaway message from HB 2674 was that local bodies need to take action on affordable housing development, themselves, or else the State might step in and do it for them.

    Kaiser moved from the House to the Senate in the last election and kept up his efforts at legislative reform. Early in the most recent legislative session, he introduced another controversial bill that would have given developers permission by right to build multifamily projects on any property near a light rail or streetcar line, significantly revised downward the parking requirements for new multifamily construction, established strict zoning request approval timelines and limited the public comment/opposition timelines and options on planned developments. The changes would have applied in any municipality with more than 25,000 residents.

    That bill once again encountered opposition from various “neighborhood preservation” groups and municipalities, particularly in the form of the League of Arizona Cities and Towns. Over the course of the session, Kaiser and the League reached a compromise that raised the population minimum to 50,000 residents, required cities to approve Auxiliary Dwelling Units (detached backyard casitas) and allowed developers with approved proposals to create properties without waiting for additional inspections.

    Municipalities subject to the law would also have had to enact at least two out of three infill development-targeted policies, including designating acceptable areas to build duplexes, triplexes or quadplexes, allowing manufactured housing community construction and/or allowing home construction on lots as small as 5KSF. (AZBEX June 14, 2023)

    That bill ultimately failed, and Kaiser resigned his Senate seat to spend more time with his family and to lead the Arizona Prosperity Project, a non-profit he founded to develop conservative policies and increase conservative representation in the Legislature and on school boards.

    Local Affordability Programs

    The degree of inclusionary and other affordability-related autonomy granted to municipalities despite the general inclusionary zoning prohibitions has led to some creative programming around the state.

    One of the most comprehensive programs is the City of Tempe’s Hometown for All initiative, proposed in 2020 and approved in early 2021. Under the program, 50% of some permitting fees paid by developers go to the Tempe Coalition for Affordable Housing. According to the press release announcing the initiative, “The funds could be used to buy and rehabilitate properties, or to buy land and request competitive offers from developers or nonprofit partners to build affordable or workforce units.”

    The City of Phoenix recently announced its own planned program for Auxiliary Dwelling Units. A new proposal would allow backyard casitas, duplexes and triplexes, which housing advocates call “the missing middle” in housing supply development, since they fall between individual single-family homes and traditional multifamily developments.

    While the proposal has the support of housing advocates, some neighborhood groups like the Arizona Neighborhood Alliance, have expressed concern the program could lead to a surge in new short-term rentals, which are a constant source of irritation for both neighborhood groups and housing advocates alike.

    Resident groups oppose STRs because they feel the rotating residents bring crime, public nuisance behavior and other problems to their areas. Advocates oppose them because they take viable long-term housing units off the market. Under state law, cities can impose some regulations on STRs, such as requiring registration, but they cannot prohibit them.

    Phoenix’s proposal seeks to limit the potential for ADUs to be used as STRs. A special permit would be required to build or rent the units, which would be restricted to building on single-family lots, and the owner would be required to live on the property full-time.

    The measure is expected to go before the Phoenix City Council in September.

    Accessory Dwelling Units ADU affordable housing Arizona Neighborhood Alliance Arizona Prosperity Project Arizona Revised Statutes 12-1131 ARS 11-819 Auxiliary Dwelling Units César Chávez City of Phoenix City of Tempe density bonus development agreement development incentive height bonus Hinckley Allen & Snyder Hometown for All House Bill 2674 inclusionary zoning League of Arizona Cities and Towns legislation Melody Hernandez NASB National Association of Home Builders neighborhood preservation NIMBY Phoenix City Council Prop 207 Proposition 207 public policy short term rental Steve Kaiser STR Tempe Coalition for Affordable Housing The Private Property Rights Protection Act
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    Scottsdale Hospitals War May Heat Up with New Banner Request

    July 29, 2025

    Dominium Planning 304-Unit BTR in Surprise

    July 29, 2025

    BNSF Looks to Combine Plan Amendment, Rezoning in 1 County Hearing

    July 25, 2025

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Our Picks

    Eloy P&Z Hears Dual Requests for Major Land Use Overhaul

    August 1, 2025

    State’s Largest Data Center Project Part of Vermaland Pinal Plan

    August 1, 2025

    Pinal Considering 215-Acre Data Center Development

    August 1, 2025

    Hundred-Unit Skyline Towns Townhome Development Moves Forward in Apache Junction

    August 1, 2025
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • YouTube
    Don't Miss
    Planning & Development

    Eloy P&Z Hears Dual Requests for Major Land Use Overhaul

    August 1, 20250

    By Roland Murphy for AZBEX In its July 16 meeting, the Eloy Planning and Zoning…

    State’s Largest Data Center Project Part of Vermaland Pinal Plan

    August 1, 2025

    Pinal Considering 215-Acre Data Center Development

    August 1, 2025

    Hundred-Unit Skyline Towns Townhome Development Moves Forward in Apache Junction

    August 1, 2025

    BEX serves architecture, engineering and construction firms as well as all the ancillary product and service categories that market to them. These include manufacturing representatives, public agencies and private real estate organizations, specialty subcontractors and services providers related to our industry.

    Our Picks

    Eloy P&Z Hears Dual Requests for Major Land Use Overhaul

    August 1, 2025

    State’s Largest Data Center Project Part of Vermaland Pinal Plan

    August 1, 2025

    Pinal Considering 215-Acre Data Center Development

    August 1, 2025
    Contact Us

    Phone: 480-709-4190
    Address: P.O. Box 12196 Tempe, AZ 85284
    Email: sales@azbex.com

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.