What's Hot

    Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail

    May 30, 2025

    Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa

    May 30, 2025

    Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department

    May 30, 2025
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    AZBEX
    NEWS TICKER
    • [May 30, 2025] - Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail
    • [May 30, 2025] - Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa
    • [May 30, 2025] - Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department
    • [May 30, 2025] - Arizona Projects 05-30-25
    • [May 28, 2025] - Split Vote Complicates Plans for VAI Resort
    • [May 28, 2025] - Safford Approves 165-Unit Multifamily Development
    • [May 27, 2025] - JDM Proposal Reimagines Biltmore Infill Project
    • [May 27, 2025] - $500M Whiteriver Hospital Preparations Advancing
    Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
    • Home
    • News
      1. View Latest
      2. Planning & Development
      3. Local News
      4. Classifieds
      5. Editorial Analysis
      6. Budgets & Funding
      7. Commercial Real Estate
      8. People on the Move
      9. Arizona Projects
      10. Legislation & Regulations
      11. Trends

      Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail

      May 30, 2025

      Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa

      May 30, 2025

      Split Vote Complicates Plans for VAI Resort

      May 28, 2025

      Safford Approves 165-Unit Multifamily Development

      May 28, 2025

      Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department

      May 30, 2025

      EdgeCore 44-Acre Mesa Land Buy Sets Up Massive Expansion

      May 23, 2025

      Ariz. Construction Added 2,400 Jobs in April

      May 21, 2025

      Phoenix Considering Data Center Development Restrictions

      May 21, 2025

      Glendale Voters to Determine VAI Resort’s Fate

      May 16, 2025

      Legislation Would Effectively Strip NIMBYs of Referendum Tool

      February 11, 2025

      2025 Forecast Tries to Clarify an Uncertain Market

      February 7, 2025

      KOREPlex Buckeye Site Quietly Listed For Sale

      January 31, 2025

      Peoria Council Approves $1.9B 10-Year CIP

      May 27, 2025

      Scottsdale Water Needs $50M for ‘Toilet to Taps’

      May 9, 2025

      Phoenix Releases $11.5B, 5-Year CIP with Nearly 1,000 Projects

      April 1, 2025

      Buckeye Starts Planning Bond Funding Outlays

      February 26, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 05-27-25

      May 27, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 05-20-25

      May 21, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 05-13-25

      May 13, 2025

      Commercial Real Estate 05-06-25

      May 6, 2025

      Industry Professionals 05-27-25

      May 27, 2025

      Industry Professionals 05-20-25

      May 21, 2025

      Industry Professionals 05-13-25

      May 13, 2025

      Industry Professionals 05-06-25

      May 6, 2025

      Arizona Projects 05-30-25

      May 30, 2025

      Arizona Projects 05-23-25

      May 23, 2025

      Arizona Projects 05-16-25

      May 16, 2025

      Arizona Projects 05-09-25

      May 9, 2025

      Phoenix Considering Data Center Development Restrictions

      May 21, 2025

      Glendale Voters to Determine VAI Resort’s Fate

      May 16, 2025

      Executive Order Will Streamline Federal Acquisition Regulations System

      April 26, 2025

      Legislation to Save Axon Plan Continues to Advance

      April 16, 2025

      Ariz. Construction Added 2,400 Jobs in April

      May 21, 2025

      Backlogs, Confidence Increase in April

      May 16, 2025

      Multifamily Developer Confidence Down in Q1

      May 13, 2025

      U.S. Construction Added 11,000 Jobs in April

      May 6, 2025

      Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail

      May 30, 2025

      Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa

      May 30, 2025

      Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department

      May 30, 2025

      Arizona Projects 05-30-25

      May 30, 2025
    • AZBEX
      • Subscribe
      • Classifieds
      • Advertising
    • DATABEX
      • Webinars
      • Monthly Snapshot
    • Events
      • 2025 Mid-Year Update
    • About Us
      • Meet the Company
      • Meet the Sales Team
      • Meet the Editorial Team
      • Meet the BEXperts
    AZBEX
    Home » Local News » Comprehensive Surprise PAD Revision Encounters Hurdles 
    Local News

    Comprehensive Surprise PAD Revision Encounters Hurdles 

    BEX StaffBy BEX StaffApril 28, 2023No Comments5 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    By Roland Murphy for AZBEX 

    The scope of a Planned Area Development request in Surprise, coupled with a degree of neighborhood opposition, is raising complications for yet another long-term development project and adding to Surprise’s growing reputation as a municipality where it is difficult to get responsible growth planning done. 

    A proposed major Planned Area Development amendment in Surprise could change 73.8 acres of commercial/institutional area in the Sycamore Farms PAD to multifamily residential. The revision would change the land use plan, development standards and dwelling unit counts for a one-square-mile area bounded by Cactus Road, Sarival Avenue, Peoria Avenue and Cotton Lane, with the Loop 303 freeway running north-south through the middle of the site. 

    The request would change four parcels on the site and allow up to 946 new housing units, including the addition of Build-to-Rent as a newly permitted housing type. According to the staff report prepared for the Surprise Planning and Zoning Commission, “This results in a total allowed dwelling unit count of 3,801 across the entirety of Sycamore Farms, which encompasses 637.6 acres, and a density of 5.96 du/ac.” 

    The request also includes an amendment that would allow for by-right inclusion of a home improvement center “with or without outdoor ancillary uses.” The current PAD allows such use with a Conditional Use Permit but is limited to indoor uses only.  

    In addition to specific considerations set aside for the Loop 303 freeway, there are a total of 18 parcels in the Sycamore Farms PAD, which includes commercial, mixed-use, and low- medium-, medium-high- and high-density residential. 

    The current proposal could change the land use plan for four parcels. 

    “In total, the proposed amendment would result in 73.8 acres of commercial/institutional land being redesignated as multi-family residential,” according to the staff analysis. 

    Along with those land use changes, the analysis says, “The subject amendment proposes to include an additional designation of MHDR-2 to specifically accommodate the single family for rent or build-to-rent development type. Parcels 11B, 16, and 6 are proposed to hold this designation, and the mixed-use Parcel 5 will also allow for this development type. Associated development standards have been created for MHDR-2 and are consistent with the other multi-family residential development standards within the PAD.” 

    The new multifamily parcels in the PAD would be set with the following unit maximums: 

    • Parcel 1B: 288 units; 
    • Parcel 6: 128 units; 
    • Parcel 11B: 400 units, and 
    • Parcel 16: 130 units. 

    Development of the various parcels under the plan would be performed in various phases with different developers and timelines directed by perceived market needs and timing. 

    Resident Encounters and NIMBYism 

    Between the request’s original submittal and the time it came before P&Z, there was one required virtual, one required in-person and one optional in-person meeting held with surrounding residents. Additional door-to-door outreach efforts were also held. 

    During the various meetings, residents brought forward what has become a standard set of opposition points around the Valley—first and foremost being a desire for commercial instead of multifamily. 

    Supporting that opposition is the set of disproven beliefs that multifamily breeds crime, lowers property values, overburdens infrastructure and adds more traffic than commercial or office, all of which are demonstrably false. 

    Several residents spoke at the April 6 P&Z meeting, and these points were presented once again. Jason Morris of Withey Morris Baugh and other applicant representatives addressed these concerns both in the resident meetings and before the Commission. 

    As Scottsdale City Councilmember Tammy Caputi said in a recent housing symposium, however, “There is no amount of facts that can change (these people’s) minds.” 

    The History and Outcome of the Request 

    Since this set of revisions is far more extensive and detailed than most of the PAD amendments making their way through the approval process, AZBEX contacted Morris for clarification on the application following the April 6 Planning and Zoning Commission hearing. He explained it arose because multiple parties were looking at multiple, smaller changes in the PAD, and P&Z and planning staff recommended they all work together to deliver an omnibus change application. 

    “We all came to the City of Surprise independently on different parcels within Sycamore Farms,” Morris explained to the Commission during the applicants’ presentation in the meeting. “It didn’t make sense for six different applications to occur all at the same time within one master plan… with different applications and different uses. It was suggested we all get together and make this a joint application so that the Planning Commission and staff could consider the totality of the changes within all of Sycamore Farms even though there are fractured owners and different owners, different applicants for this application.” 

    He further explained the resulting application was, effectively, six cases, despite being one agenda item. He also praised the quality of the staff analysis and review in preparing the explanation of the overall proposal in terms Commission members could easily understand.  

    In watching the Members’ response to the applicants’ presentation, and despite the detailed application and simplified staff analysis, both speakers against the project and Commissioners, themselves, seemed perplexed by the individual items and their economic justifications.  

    After extensive discussion between Members—with some leaning in favor of the entire application, some leaning toward rejection, and some leaning to send the omnibus application back to the applicants to be redivided back into its separate pieces—the Commission ultimately voted on yet another option.  

    The final motion sought to recommend Council approve the requested changes for Parcel 11 but leave the uses for Parcels 1, 6 and 16 as they are currently stated. 

    Surprise City Council is scheduled to take up the original application and the Commission’s recommendation at its May 2 meeting. It is expected there will be a variety of negotiations between staff and applicant representatives in the interim, which will likely result in additional changes. 

    apartments/condos City of Surprise commercial master plan multifamily Planned Area Development amendment Private Scottsdale City Councilmember single-family Surprise Planning and Zoning Sycamore Farms PAD
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail

    May 30, 2025

    Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa

    May 30, 2025

    Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department

    May 30, 2025

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Our Picks

    Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail

    May 30, 2025

    Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa

    May 30, 2025

    Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department

    May 30, 2025

    Arizona Projects 05-30-25

    May 30, 2025
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • YouTube
    Don't Miss
    Planning & Development

    Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail

    May 30, 20250

    By Roland Murphy for AZBEX The City of Phoenix wants to transform the 19th Avenue…

    Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa

    May 30, 2025

    Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department

    May 30, 2025

    Arizona Projects 05-30-25

    May 30, 2025

    BEX serves architecture, engineering and construction firms as well as all the ancillary product and service categories that market to them. These include manufacturing representatives, public agencies and private real estate organizations, specialty subcontractors and services providers related to our industry.

    Our Picks

    Phoenix Wants Multifamily Mixed-Use at 19th & Dunlap Light Rail

    May 30, 2025

    Senior/Assisted Living Center Proposed in Maricopa

    May 30, 2025

    Scottsdale Establishes Transportation & Infrastructure Department

    May 30, 2025
    Contact Us

    Phone: 480-709-4190
    Address: P.O. Box 12196 Tempe, AZ 85284
    Email: sales@azbex.com

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.